Emmerdale has never shied away from heavy drama, but fans now say the soap has crossed a line. Viewers across social media are calling the current episodes frustrating, illogical, and overwhelmingly bleak, with several insisting the show has become “unwatchable.”

Below, we break down the growing backlash — and why fans say the latest story arcs have left them exhausted.

A Cluster of Dark, Interconnected Plots

The soap is currently juggling several intense storylines at once:

• Robert Sugden’s prison flashbacks, dominated by manipulative new inmate Kev, which have stalled Robert and Aaron’s reunion.

• April and Dylan’s trafficking storyline, with Ray and Celia forcing April into sex work.

• Bear Wolf’s imprisonment, revealing he and Anya are victims of modern slavery on Celia’s farm.

• Charity’s pregnancy deception, as she hides the true identity of her baby’s father from Mack.

Each arc is emotionally heavy on its own — but airing them simultaneously has left viewers overwhelmed.

“Too Depressing, Too Illogical” — Fans Speak Out

A long-time viewer on Reddit summed up the frustration:

“I’ve watched for twenty years but I can’t anymore. Celia, Kev, and Robert’s plots are exhausting. I love Robron, but it’s just painful now. Aaron used to be the strongest man in the village. Now he’s terrified of Kev?”

Others pointed out glaring logic gaps:

• Moira, supposedly Celia’s farming partner, never noticed Bear imprisoned on her property.

• Ray, who’s terrified of Ross, somehow runs a criminal operation unchecked.

• Paddy conveniently didn’t inspect Celia’s animals despite saying he would.

• Robert and Kev’s vow renewal had only two people present, making the scene feel “unfinished” and “strangely executed.”

Another viewer added:

“There are no light-hearted stories anymore. Everything is dark, everything is trauma. It’s just depressing.”

Why The Backlash Matters

Emmerdale is known for its emotional depth, but viewers say the current pacing leaves no room to breathe. With multiple heavy arcs overlapping, watchers feel weighed down by a relentless flow of misery and contrived twists.

And while the show is tackling important issues — exploitation, trafficking, mental health, coercion — fans argue the execution feels rushed, inconsistent and sometimes unrealistic.

Is Emmerdale Losing Its Balance?

While some viewers still enjoy the high-stakes storytelling, there’s no denying the mood has shifted. Without lighter stories or everyday character moments to break the tension, even long-time watchers say the soap feels “draining.”

As one fan put it:

“I used to prefer Emmerdale over Corrie. Now it’s hard to sit through.